When people talk about giving electric car batteries a second life, they usually ask two questions. Does it pay off? And is it good for the climate? A third question gets far less attention: is it good for people? A new CIRCUBATT study uses a social life cycle assessment to find out who benefits from second life batteries, and who might be left behind.
Our public Social Life Cycle Assessment, led by the University of Greenwich, looks at second life batteries used in Battery as a Service models. In this model, customers pay for the energy service rather than owning the battery. You can learn more in our plain language guide to Battery as a Service.
What is a social life cycle assessment?
Most people have heard of a life cycle assessment. It measures a product’s environmental footprint, from raw materials to disposal. A social life cycle assessment applies the same logic to people. Instead of counting emissions, it looks at working conditions, safety, fair competition, privacy and the wellbeing of local communities.
The CIRCUBATT team based its work on the UNEP Guidelines for Social Life Cycle Assessment, the international reference for this type of study. The assessment follows a battery from the moment it retires from a car, through its preparation and second life use, until it reaches the end of that second life.
How the study worked
The researchers built a framework with 36 social themes and more than 100 indicators. Ten experts from industry, research and standardisation then rated how important each theme was. After that, 165 people from 21 countries took part in a survey about the expected social impacts.
The study grouped the people affected into five stakeholder groups: workers, consumers, value chain actors such as suppliers and partners, society at large, and local communities. It then compared four different second life uses for a retired EV battery.
Who benefits from second life batteries?
The overall picture is positive. Across all five groups, current social performance scores above zero. The expected impacts, however, are unequal.
Workers and consumers come out best. Second life activities create new jobs in testing, repurposing and installation, and they can offer consumers more affordable energy storage. Value chain actors also see a positive effect, although a smaller one.
Society at large and local communities are the only groups with slightly negative expected impacts. For society, high upfront costs limit how widely the technology spreads and how much it contributes to the economy. For local communities, concerns include where facilities are located, effects on living conditions and limited local employment.
Four second lives compared in the social life cycle assessment
The study compared four ways to reuse an EV battery: backup power for resilience, energy arbitrage and grid services, portable and off grid uses, and urban mobility.
Backup power came out as the most socially favourable option, mainly because it scored best for local communities and value chain actors. Grid services and portable uses formed a middle tier. Urban mobility ranked lowest, largely because of its weaker results for local communities. That said, the differences between the four uses are small, so none of them should be ruled out.
The hotspots that need attention
The assessment also pinpoints specific risks, which the authors call hotspots. For workers, the main concerns are long working hours and pay gaps linked to gender and minority status. For value chain actors, fair competition and intellectual property rights stand out.
Consumers raise a very modern worry: privacy and cybersecurity. Second life batteries in Battery as a Service models are often connected and monitored, which means data must be protected. Finally, local communities remain the most consistent hotspot across all four uses.
What should change?
Based on these findings, the report recommends five practical steps. First, strengthen labour protections in second life activities. Second, codify safety standards and training for repurposed battery storage. Third, clarify the rules on intellectual property and competition.
Fourth, design privacy into connected battery services from the start. Fifth, engage local communities early, choose sites carefully and hire locally. Several of these points echo our recent study on second life battery policy, which also identified safety codes and skills as major gaps.
An early but important baseline
This is an interim result, and the authors are open about its limits. The scores reflect expert and public perceptions rather than measured outcomes, and the expert panel was small. A final version is planned for June 2027, when markets and technologies will have matured further.
Even so, the study offers something rare: a transparent way to compare second life uses by their social impact, not just by cost or carbon. Read about the climate side in Recycle or Reuse? What Really Shapes a Second Life Battery’s Carbon Footprint, or visit our frequently asked questions.

